For my Les Pauls, I just dig the plain tops, and though I’m not averse to flame tops, they’re not my first choice – at least for Les Pauls. My ’59 replica has a very subtle flame that is only apparent when you look at the guitar from the side. But head-on, it looks like a very cool plain top, and that’s what really appealed to me about that guitar. Having said that, I dig flame tops on other guitars. For instance, my Gibson Nighthawk has this really cool flame that combined with the translucent amber finish, give it an incredible 3D effect. If it was a plain top or just opaque lacquer, think it would lose its charm.
What are your preferences?
Guitar Gear 
As usual G’Dawd… I like em all..
My Les Paul Custom Lite with a plain top is amazing… So is the quilt on my
G&L (Best looking G&L top I’ve seen)
Or the Bass Boat finish on one of my
WR’s..
Can’t find a pic of my Custom lite….
I never used to be a Flame fan, now I have two lol!
http://www.guitarnoize.com/blog/comments/suhr-s4-vs-suhr-modern-comparison-video
My favorite: Faded lacquer burst, mild flame, nice figure, with mineral streaks. But I will take any in the Beauty of the Burst book!!!
I am a fan of flame tops. I think flamed wood is gorgeous, and it’s cool to see that highlighted on what I consider playable art. That being said, I also like a good iced tea burst plain top.